Sort + Filter
Show

Return to Tiffany & Co. Jewelry

Discover authentic, pre-owned Return to Tiffany & Co. necklaces, bracelets, charms, and pendants, including vintage and discontinued designs. With over 20 years of experience and more than 75,000 Tiffany pieces sold, The Silver Trove is your trusted source for genuine pre-owned Tiffany jewelry.

Return to Tiffany Blue Enamel Heart Tag Charm or Pendant Return to Tiffany Blue Enamel Heart Tag Charm or Pendant - 0

Return to Tiffany Blue Enamel Heart Tag Charm or Pendant

$319.00
Return to Tiffany Chain Links Repair Lengthen Center Heart Tag Necklace Bracelet Return to Tiffany Chain Links Repair Lengthen Center Heart Tag Necklace Bracelet - 0

Return to Tiffany Chain Links Repair Lengthen Center Heart Tag Necklace Bracelet

$145.00
Return to Tiffany Green Enamel Heart Tag Charm or Pendant in Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Green Enamel Heart Tag Charm or Pendant in Sterling Silver - 0

Return to Tiffany Green Enamel Heart Tag Charm or Pendant in Sterling Silver

$209.00
Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Etched Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Etched Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver - 0

Return to Tiffany Heart Tag Etched Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver

$182.00
Return to Tiffany Oval Cufflink in Sterling Silver 1 Single Replacement For Lost Return to Tiffany Oval Cufflink in Sterling Silver 1 Single Replacement For Lost - 0

Return to Tiffany Oval Cufflink in Sterling Silver 1 Single Replacement For Lost

$149.00
Return to Tiffany Round Drop Dangle Hook Earrings in Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Round Drop Dangle Hook Earrings in Sterling Silver - 0

Return to Tiffany Round Drop Dangle Hook Earrings in Sterling Silver

$389.00
Return to Tiffany Round Drop Hook Earring, 1 replacement Earring Return to Tiffany Round Drop Hook Earring, 1 replacement Earring - 0

Return to Tiffany Round Drop Hook Earring, 1 replacement Earring

$205.00
Return to Tiffany Round Key Pendant in Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Round Key Pendant in Sterling Silver - 0

Return to Tiffany Round Key Pendant in Sterling Silver

$339.00
Return to Tiffany Round Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Round Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver - 0

Return to Tiffany Round Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver

$169.00
Return to Tiffany Round Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Round Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver - 0

Return to Tiffany Round Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver

$149.00
Return to Tiffany Small Heart Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Small Heart Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver - 0

Return to Tiffany Small Heart Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver

$175.00
Return to Tiffany Small Heart Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Small Heart Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver - 0

Return to Tiffany Small Heart Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver

$175.00
Return to Tiffany Small Heart Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Small Heart Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver - 0

Return to Tiffany Small Heart Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver

$175.00
Return to Tiffany Wide Heart Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver Return to Tiffany Wide Heart Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver - 0

Return to Tiffany Wide Heart Tag Pendant or Charm in Sterling Silver

$169.00
Return to Tiffany& Co. Round Heart Charm or Pendant in Blue enamel and Silver Return to Tiffany& Co. Round Heart Charm or Pendant in Blue enamel and Silver - 0

Return to Tiffany& Co. Round Heart Charm or Pendant in Blue enamel and Silver

$389.00
Size 5 Please Return to Tiffany & Co Oval Signet Ring in Sterling Silver Size 5 Please Return to Tiffany & Co Oval Signet Ring in Sterling Silver - 0

Size 5 Please Return to Tiffany & Co Oval Signet Ring in Sterling Silver

$289.00
Size 5 Please Return to Tiffany & Co Oval Signet Ring in Sterling Silver Size 5 Please Return to Tiffany & Co Oval Signet Ring in Sterling Silver - 0

Size 5 Please Return to Tiffany & Co Oval Signet Ring in Sterling Silver

$289.00
Size 6.25" Please Return to Tiffany & Co Wide Cuff Bracelet in Sterling Silver Size 6.25" Please Return to Tiffany & Co Wide Cuff Bracelet in Sterling Silver - 0

Size 6.25" Please Return to Tiffany & Co Wide Cuff Bracelet in Sterling Silver

$1,250.00
Size 8.5 Please Return to Tiffany Oval Signet Ring in Sterling Silver AUTHENTIC Size 8.5 Please Return to Tiffany Oval Signet Ring in Sterling Silver AUTHENTIC - 0

Size 8.5 Please Return to Tiffany Oval Signet Ring in Sterling Silver AUTHENTIC

$389.00
Tiffany Replacement Heart Tag Round Circle Toggle Necklace Bracelet Clasp Repair Tiffany Replacement Heart Tag Round Circle Toggle Necklace Bracelet Clasp Repair - 0

Tiffany Replacement Heart Tag Round Circle Toggle Necklace Bracelet Clasp Repair

$145.00